# “Not Only Defended But Also Applied”: The Perceived Absurdity of Bayesian Inference

@article{Gelman2010NotOD, title={“Not Only Defended But Also Applied”: The Perceived Absurdity of Bayesian Inference}, author={Andrew Gelman and Christian P. Robert}, journal={The American Statistician}, year={2010}, volume={67}, pages={1 - 5} }

The missionary zeal of many Bayesians of old has been matched, in the other direction, by an attitude among some theoreticians that Bayesian methods were absurd—not merely misguided but obviously wrong in principle. We consider several examples, beginning with Feller's classic text on probability theory and continuing with more recent cases such as the perceived Bayesian nature of the so-called doomsday argument. We analyze in this note the intellectual background behind various misconceptions… Expand

#### Paper Mentions

#### 26 Citations

Discussion: Bayesian Methods: Applied? Yes. Philosophical Defense? In Flux

- Computer Science
- 2013

The state of Bayesian statistics in the twenty-first century is strong and it is useful to know the scientific and philosophical basis forBayesian statistics, not only the techniques that allow its application. Expand

Comment: Bayesian Ideas Reemerged in the 1950s

- Sociology
- 2013

a trade secret by the television network NBC for some time. There is a sense in which Feller was right in that Bayesian methods at the time he wrote (1950) had been defended but not applied. If there… Expand

Doomsday: Two Flaws.

- Physics, Computer Science
- 2019

Here I argue that the much-discussed Doomsday Argument (DA) has two flaws. Its mathematical flaw stems from applying frequentist probability or faulty Bayesian inference. Its conceptual flaw is… Expand

Statistical Inference as Severe Testing

- Computer Science
- 2018

This book pulls back the cover on disagreements between experts charged with restoring integrity to science, and denies two pervasive views of the role of probability in inference: to assign degrees of belief, and to control error rates in a long run. Expand

Conflicts in Bayesian Statistics Between Inference Based on Credible Intervals and Bayes Factors

- Mathematics
- 2020

In frequentist statistics, point-null hypothesis testing based on significance tests and confidence intervals are harmonious procedures and lead to the same conclusion. This is not the case in the… Expand

The Need for Adding Judgment in Bayesian Prediction

- Mathematics, Computer Science
- Int. J. Inf. Technol. Decis. Mak.
- 2016

This research extends the use of Bayes’ theorem by incorporating judgments within the framework of the frequently used decision theory, the analytic network process (ANP) and illustrates its use with an application. Expand

Very Tentative Introductory Syllabus

- Psychology
- 2014

This is a very tentative reading list. I hope to modify it in response to your suggestions and as you help me with topic selection. You also will note that I emphasize my own work in the “required… Expand

How do we choose our default methods

- Computer Science
- 2014

The informal criteria the authors use to decide what methods to use and what principles to apply in statistics problems are considered. Expand

Prototypes, exemplars and the response scaling parameter: A Bayes factor perspective

- Psychology
- 2016

Abstract The Bayes factor can be used to break the stalemate between prototype and exemplar theorists in category learning. Exemplar theorists do not accept prototype theorists’ results, because… Expand

A tutorial on Bayesian multi-model linear regression with BAS and JASP.

- Medicine
- Behavior research methods
- 2021

A tutorial on linear regression using Bayesian model averaging in JASP, based on the BAS package in R, and a demonstration of the method on an example data set from the World Happiness Report is demonstrated. Expand

#### References

SHOWING 1-10 OF 43 REFERENCES

Why Isn't Everyone a Bayesian?

- Mathematics
- 1986

Abstract Originally a talk delivered at a conference on Bayesian statistics, this article attempts to answer the following question: why is most scientific data analysis carried out in a non-Bayesian… Expand

Introductory Remarks on Metastatistics for the Practically Minded Non-Bayesian Regression Runner

- Psychology
- 2009

It would appear that much debate among practically minded researchers in economics, social science, and in other fields, is rooted in (frequently) unstated assumptions about the underlying… Expand

Puzzles of Anthropic Reasoning Resolved Using Full Non-indexical Conditioning

- Mathematics, Physics
- 2006

I consider the puzzles arising from four interrelated problems involving `anthropic' reasoning, and in particular the `Self-Sampling Assumption' (SSA) - that one should reason as if one were randomly… Expand

An attempt at reading Keynes' Treatise on Probability

- Philosophy, Mathematics
- 2010

The book A Treatise on Probability was published by John Maynard Keynes in 1921. It contains a critical assessment of the foundations of probability and of the current statistical methodology. As a… Expand

You May Believe You Are a Bayesian But You Are Probably Wrong

- Mathematics
- 2011

An elementary sketch of some issues in statistical inference and in particular of the central role of likelihood is given. This is followed by brief outlines of what George Barnard considered were… Expand

Probability, Statistics and Truth

- Nature
- 1940

THIS book is scarcely the philosophical treatise which its title may suggest. It is the written-up version of six lectures on probability and applications, as conceived from von Mises' special… Expand

Is Bayes Posterior just Quick and Dirty Confidence

- Mathematics
- 2011

Bayes (1763) introduced the observed likelihood function to statistical inference and pro- vided a weight function to calibrate the parameter; he also introduced a condence results were dierent when… Expand

Subjectivism — a reply in defence of classical actuarial methods

- Computer Science
- 1976

The author presented a paper which defended the methods and approach of the founders of that profession against criticism from some of the more statistically minded actuaries, and a considerable section of the paper was devoted to risk theory. Expand

Calculated Risks: How to Know When Numbers Deceive You

- Medicine
- 2002

Cognitive scientist Gerd Gigerenzer explains how the authors can overcome their ignorance of numbers and better understand the risks they may be taking with their money, their health, and their lives. Expand

Natural induction: An objective bayesian approach

- Mathematics
- 2009

The statistical analysis of a sample taken from a finite population is a classic problem for which no generally accepted objective Bayesian results seem to exist. Bayesian solutions to this problem… Expand